Thanksgiving Preorder Menu

Thanksgiving preorders are now CLOSED! Pickup is one day only, Wednesday, November 26th between 10am and 2pm.

Please select Thanksgiving Preorder Pickup Wednesday November 26th for your pickup date when checking out.

Preorders close Wednesday November 19th at 10am.

Thank you for including us on your Thanksgiving table. We can’t wait to bake for you.

Thanksgiving Old Fashioned Pecan Pie
$44.00

A classic pecan pie made with old-fashioned Steen’s cane syrup and salted, toasted pecan pieces. 9-inch pie, serves 6.

Thanksgiving Burnt Basque Cheesecake
$45.00

A crustless cheesecake cooked at a high temperature, creating an addictive crumbly cheese crust, a dark caramelized top, and a sweet, creamy center.

Please note, as of January 1, 2026 our cheesecake is slightly smaller than previous, and still serves 6-8.

Thanksgiving Double Crust Apple Pie
$44.00

A blend of sweet and tart apples tossed in house-made caramel, browned butter and apple pie spices, and topped with our buttery crust. 9-inch pie, serves 6.

Thanksgiving Ham and Cheese Quiche
$44.00

House-made quiche filled with ham and swiss cheese. Serves 6.

Thanksgiving Frozen Wonder Bun (Pack of 4)
$20.00

Four of our Wonder Buns, frozen and ready for your home oven! These come with proof and bake instructions.

Tip Our Staff
from $1.00

Please give a ‘thank you’ to our staff and select a tip!

Thanksgiving Cranberry Compote
$15.00

Fresh, locally grown cranberries are made into a tart and zingy compote complemented by fresh orange. 16 oz of compote.

Thanksgiving Brown Butter Apple Pie with Buckwheat Streusel
$44.00

Our incredibly flaky old fashioned pie dough filled with thin sliced apples tossed in brown sugar, spices and browned butter, and topped with buckwheat streusel. 9-inch pie, serves 6.

Crust may look different than pictured

Thanksgiving Caramelized Onion & Swiss Quiche, Whole
$44.00

House-made quiche filled with ribbons of caramelized onions and aged Swiss cheese. Serves 6.

Thanksgiving Bakeshop Pumpkin Pie
$40.00

Our incredibly flaky old fashioned pie dough filled with our spiced sweet potato and browned butter mixture. 9-inch pie, serves 6.